The owner of the Retreat at Iron Horse wants a 30-unit building on its garages and parking. Staff and planners oppose it; aldermen discuss it Tuesday.

The owner of the Retreat at Iron Horse apartments wants to add a 30-unit building to the complex. Franklin’s planning staff recommend the Board of Mayor and Aldermen deny it, and so does the Planning Commission.

The complex is at 145 Legends Club Lane, north of Mack Hatcher Memorial Parkway and east of Franklin Road. It has 270 apartments on 20 acres. The new building would take the total to 300.

Aldermen discuss the rezoning and the revised development plan at their 5 p.m. work session Tuesday at the Williamson County Auditorium, 1320 West Main St. They are items 4 and 5 on the Nov. 10 work session agenda. The agenda sets a public hearing for Jan. 12, 2027. The board takes no vote at a work session.

What the owner wants to build

The owner is St Iron Horse LLC, and the engineering firm Kimley-Horn filed the application. According to the city staff report, the plan would:

  • demolish four detached garage buildings on the site
  • put up one three-story building with 30 apartments
  • remove about 50 parking spaces and add 30 parallel spaces
  • defer building 31 more spaces, as city rules allow
  • rezone the land from 13.2 to 15 homes an acre

The applicant’s presentation to the Planning Commission, included in the packet, says the building would have 27 one-bedroom and three two-bedroom apartments. The one-bedroom units would average 717 square feet, against about 800 square feet for the one-bedrooms there now.

The presentation says one-bedroom rents at the complex average $2.44 a square foot. It says the smaller units would rent for $200 to $300 a month less.

It also sets out promises to current tenants:

  • construction from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m., with no noisy work before 8 a.m.
  • no work on weekends or holidays
  • contractor parking and storage on the outer row of the parking lot
  • moving people who lease the garages being torn down
  • moving residents whose buildings face the work, if they want to move
  • passes to co-working spaces for residents whose apartments face the site

Why staff and the Planning Commission oppose it

City staff said the land use plan, Envision Franklin, supports apartments on this site. The city also encourages infill housing, the report said.

The objection is to this layout. Staff said it “removes existing conveniences for current tenants, including parking.” It said the plan needs exceptions to city rules to fit the building in, which “diminishes the quality of the development.”

The deferred parking rule lets a developer wait up to 24 months after the final occupancy permit before building up to 30% of the required spaces. Staff said the plan meets current parking standards on paper. But “the immediate need and demand for parking may not be met,” the report said.

The plan asks for three exceptions, called modifications of standards:

Request Staff Planning Commission
Keep the existing perpendicular spaces by the clubhouse and leasing office Approve 7-0
No parallel parking in front of the new building Deny 4-3 to disapprove
Planting strip beside the building, not beside the curb Deny 5-2

The packet does not say which way the 5-2 vote on the planting strip went.

Staff said the 30 apartments would add fewer than 20 car trips at peak hours. It added that Franklin Road already has “significant delays” at rush hour and the extra homes “will add to the delay.” The city is weighing options for widening Franklin Road north of Mack Hatcher.

The Franklin Municipal Planning Commission voted 5-2 on Oct. 22 to recommend disapproval of both the rezoning and the plan. One member recused.

What residents told the city

The packet holds six emails from people who live at the complex, all opposed. One was sent on behalf of what it calls more than 30 residents, with a signed petition attached.

That email lists the loss of parking near their buildings, the loss of the garages and changes to the grounds. It says about 50 residents went to a meeting the owner held and all objected.

What it means for you

  • If you live at the Retreat at Iron Horse: nothing changes unless aldermen approve both the rezoning and the plan. That cannot happen before the Jan. 12, 2027, public hearing.
  • To comment: email recorder@franklintn.gov before noon on a meeting day, or speak in person. Comments become part of the record.
  • If you drive Franklin Road: staff expect a small rise in peak-hour traffic on a road staff already call congested.

The board can still approve the plan against the Planning Commission’s advice. Another apartment plan on Franklin Road, Harpeth Village, goes to its own public hearing Tuesday night.